Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Yvette N's avatar

Watching this on video is as good as having seen it in person! I'm glad to have done both. Excellent discussion! I will not relinquish my incredulity.

Steersman's avatar

> Is there such a thing as true trans? Lionel Shriver doesn’t think so."

Kinda think you lot are barking up the wrong tree, are more part of the problem than of the solution. Notably in refusing, if not being incapable, of defining exactly what you mean by "gender".

Even on a more less scientifically tenable definition for "gender" -- one endorsed by salient "sects" of feminism, i.e., "sexually dimorphic behavioural and personality traits typical of each sex but not unique to either" -- your "transgender child" is simply equivalent to your own "gender-nonconforming" one, to tomboys, to feminine males, to masculine females.

There really is no problem in that conception, in that idea, at least that I can see. The problems mushroom when transgender ideologues, political opportunists, and scientific illiterates insist or claim that manifesting such "gender-nonconforming" traits is prima facie evidence of BEING of the other sex.

Kinda think y'all need to spend some time separating wheat and chaff, separating what it takes to qualify as male and female from secondary traits typical of each sex but not unique to either.

1 more comment...

Ready for more?