
In 2023, I, together with a small group of others, launched a citizens’ petition in Portugal. With no institutional, political or media support whatsoever, it gathered 18,000 signatures in five days and approached 50,000 within a few weeks.
We asked Parliament to reconsider a law introducing gender self-identification into schools from a very young age, including: changes of name and gender, access to toilets and changing rooms according to self-perceived gender identity, and measures that could sideline parents and encourage social transition before the causes of a child’s distress had been properly explored. (História de uma petição cívica num Portugal cada vez menos democrático)
The response was revealing. We were accused of spreading fake news, and the then Socialist parliamentary leader went so far as to describe the petition’s signatories as “fanatics”. (A nossa campanha contra uma lei abusiva e perigosa)
Three years later, however, the world has changed faster than Portugal.
The Cass Review and developments across several European countries have reinforced the need for caution, individualised assessment and attention to co-occurring conditions before medicalisation, particularly in minors. Recent studies from Germany and Finland have provided further reasons for caution. These are just a few examples. Yet in Portugal, the Medical Association and the Psychologists’ Association continue to support gender-affirmative approaches, including for children and young people. (O atraso crónico de Portugal)
This makes a recent interview with Reem Alsalem, UN Special Rapporteur on violence against women and girls, about the situation in Portugal particularly significant.
Alsalem reminds us of some elementary truths. “Sex matters in law,” she says, “because it matters in relation to pregnancy, reproduction, sexual violence, discrimination and the provision of sex-specific services and protection.”
Yes, you read that correctly: sex, not gender identity. Biological sex, male or female — not “assigned at birth” by anyone, because it is already inscribed in the DNA of every human being from the moment of conception.
On the medicalisation of minors, she is unequivocal:
“Important independent scientific reviews around the world have identified significant harms and unresolved risks associated with gender-affirming medical interventions (...). In children and adolescents in particular, puberty blockers are associated with reduced bone mineral density and have been shown to impact their psychological well-being, cognitive development, fertility and long-term sexual development; cross-sex hormones can also affect fertility, bone health and cardio-metabolic health.”
She concludes: “Sterilising children and preventing them from entering puberty can hardly guarantee the highest attainable standard of health to which they are entitled.”
But there is another particularly uncomfortable issue: homosexuality.
In 2024, Portugal criminalised so-called conversion practices. And let us be absolutely clear: attempts to turn homosexual people heterosexual through coercion or pseudo-therapies are indefensible — and were already prohibited and punishable under general law, without the need for the new, extremely broad 2024 law.
But it is equally indefensible to turn homosexual young people into heterosexual adults of the opposite sex — in other words, to practise what we might reasonably call “conversion therapy” from gay to trans.
Alsalem points to a striking figure from the Tavistock Clinic, the only specialist public gender-identity service for minors in the UK and one of the largest specialist services of its kind, which closed after the interim recommendations of the Cass Review and controversies over youth treatment in 2024. Among the girls and young women for whom sexual-orientation data were available, at least 70% were attracted to females — 50% were lesbian and 20% bisexual.
This does not prove that these young people would necessarily have ceased to identify as trans, nor even that they would have retained a homosexual or bisexual orientation throughout their lives, especially given the greater fluidity of sexual orientation during adolescence. It proves something much simpler: psychologists must be free to ask questions.
Is it gender dysphoria? Homosexuality? Distress about puberty? Trauma, autism, depression, abuse, bullying — or a combination of several factors?
Exploration is not conversion. Exploring and questioning are among the fundamental mechanisms psychotherapy depends on for its very existence and effectiveness.
Yet Portugal’s 2024 law is so broad that it may ultimately punish parents and healthcare professionals for fulfilling their duty to protect the best interests of their children and/or patients by asking the right questions. Indeed, Reem Alsalem warns of precisely this paradox: in trying to prevent one form of conversion, overly broad legislation may contribute to another, particularly among same-sex-attracted young people.
The same conflict between identity and sex is also putting women’s rights at risk.
In 2025, the Portuguese prison administration confirmed the existence of five biological males who had legally changed their civil identity from male to female and, as trans women, had been placed in women’s prisons. One case became particularly controversial because of the inmate’s violent behaviour, including deliberately setting fire to a cell at Tires women’s prison. The issue has since reached the courts through a class action suit against the Portuguese State, concerning “the protection of the rights of female prisoners and female prison officers, particularly their dignity, safety, physical integrity and privacy, in view of the admission of male prisoners to women’s prisons on the basis of their gender identity.”
Alsalem reminds us that many female prisoners have been victims of sexual violence and trauma. Trans people must be protected, but that protection, she says, “cannot and should not come at the expense of women.”
If we are to discuss what is happening in the current debate rationally and truthfully — a debate that is too often marked by little actual debate and a great deal of cancellation, and ideological assertions proclaimed as unquestionable, scientific truths — we must first clarify our concepts and make several essential distinctions:
Compassion does not mean automatically affirming a self-perceived gender identity. Therapeutic exploration is not conversion. Sex is always biological and cannot be replaced by vague, fluid and sometimes temporary concepts such as gender identity. And protecting one vulnerable group cannot mean ignoring another.
If we could start from there together, the debate might be far more fruitful and interesting.
And to everyone’s benefit.
Thereza Ameal is a children’s and young adult writer and author of the petition against the gender self-determination law in schools
Genspect publishes a variety of authors with different perspectives. Any opinions expressed in this article are the author’s and do not necessarily reflect Genspect’s official position. For more on Genspect, visit our FAQs.

